• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Mister Pizza: Authentic, Crispy Newburgh Pizza with Friendly Service

Mister Pizza, located in Newburgh Mall, NY, is a rising gem known for its authentic, crispy-crust pizzas that rival the finest Bronx-style slices. Since opening three months ago, this family-run spot blends heartfelt hospitality with exceptional flavors, from their signature chicken bacon ranch pie to homemade jalapeño poppers and perfectly baked garlic knots. The friendly, efficient staff welcome all diners, including those seeking plant-based options, showcasing genuine care and community spirit. Each bite bursts with balanced sauce and ideal crust texture, making every visit a rewarding experience. Mister Pizza truly stands out as a delicious destination worth discovering.

Mister Pizza at a glance

  • Address 1401 NY-300, Newburgh, NY 12550, United States
  • Phone +1 845-522-8250
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .

Photos & Gallery

Mister Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Sharon cosgrove
5

Just wanted to give a quick shout out to the new business, Mister Pizza, in the Newburgh Mall. This guy really knows how to do business. Two young girls wanted to buy two bottles of soda but they didn't have enough money, he gave it to them anyway. I told him how nice that was, he replied "they are my future customers." He said that he comes from Mexico, and he knows how difficult life can be. He opened up 3 months ago, where Cosmo's was. The food was delicious, especially the homemade jalapeno Poppers. Give him a try the next time you are in the Newburgh Mall, let's keep this guy in business

danny phillips
5

Very good chicken bacon ranch pizza! had a perfectly crispy crust with that perfect thin cracking as you fold it. The crew is very friendly and fast with service too would highly recommend

Matthew Spellman
5

This is by far one of the best pizzas I have ever had. I am always trying to find something comparable to Bronx pizza and this place is it. Tried it by the slice while sitting in and took a pie to go. Each time the slices did not bend when making the initial fold. The sauce is delicious and the crust is perfectly crispy. When doing take out the second time we ordered garlic not. They were again perfectly crispy on the outside and a doughy master piece on the inside. 10/10 barstool sports needs to come in and rate it. That’s how good it is.

Thomas
5

I recently visited this pizza shop and had an amazing experience! Firstly, the staff were incredibly friendly and accommodating. When I asked if they had any plant-based options, they were more than happy to make me a freshly made pie before closing time. It was so kind of them! Not only were the staff great, but the food was also top-notch. I couldn't resist ordering their garlic knots, and let me tell you, they were absolutely delicious. The perfect combination of softness and flavor. To wash it all down, I tried their passion fruit raspado, and it was seriously a treat for my taste buds! What impressed me the most was the efficiency of the service. Despite being a bit busy, they managed to serve our food quickly without compromising on quality. Everything was served hot and fresh! I highly recommend Mister Pizza for anyone looking for a great dining experience. I can't wait to go back and try more of their menu. Keep up the excellent work!

Location

  • Mister Pizza
    Mister Pizza
    1401 NY-300, Newburgh, NY 12550, United States Hotline: +1 845-522-8250

Located in the heart of Newburgh Mall, Mister Pizza has quickly become a standout spot for pizza lovers seeking an authentic and heartfelt experience. This newcomer at 1401 NY-300 blends the art of pizza-making with genuine community spirit. The owner, who hails from Mexico, brings not only skill but also a warmth that radiates through his approach to both business and cuisine. His welcoming nature, like the story shared by customer Sharon Cosgrove about generosity towards young patrons, sets the tone for the entire dining experience.

The true star here is the pizza itself. Customers rave about the perfectly crispy, thin crust that folds without bending—an often elusive texture found in the best New York-style pies. Matthew Spellman’s praise comparing it favorably to Bronx pizza highlights Mister Pizza’s mastery of sauce balance and crust crunch. The chicken bacon ranch pizza, recommended by Danny Phillips, showcases rich, well-layered flavors that come together in a harmonious, savory bite, while the homemade jalapeno poppers add a spicy, homemade touch that enhances the menu’s appeal.

Beyond pizza, Mister Pizza impresses with its thoughtfully crafted sides and drinks. The garlic knots, described by Thomas as a soft and flavorful masterpiece, pair perfectly with their unique passion fruit raspado—a refreshing and unexpected delight that elevates the meal. The willingness to accommodate special requests, such as plant-based pies, further reflects the flexible and customer-focused ethos of this pizzeria.

Service here is brisk yet attentive, ensuring every dish arrives fresh and hot. Mister Pizza is more than a pizza joint; it’s a place where quality ingredients, skillful cooking, and genuine hospitality converge. It’s easy to see why patrons are eager to return and why the community is rallying to support this promising new business. If you find yourself at Newburgh Mall, Mister Pizza promises a satisfying and memorable slice of New York’s best, served with heart.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Wheelchair-accessible seating
  • Service options
    • Kerbside pickup
    • No-contact delivery
    • Delivery
    • Takeaway
    • Dine-in
  • Payments
    • Debit cards
    • NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards